T07: Geological risks and natural hazardsDinesh JAGANIYA, Manish SHAH, Usha PATELDept. of Applied Mechanics, L D College of EngineeringEvaluation of natural foliation effect on deformation characteristic and shear strength parameters of Chamoli (Uttarakhand) rock using a Triaxial systemIn major part of the Chamoli, high degree of metamorphic rock are identified. The objective of this research paper is to examine the effect of natural foliation of Chamoli rock on shear characteristics and failure patterns through different anisotropic angles using an automated triaxial system. In present study, seven anisotropic angles (0°, 15°, 30°, 45°, 60°, 75°, and 90°) were simulated on a cylindrical specimen of diameter 50mm and length of 100mm based on the natural foliation of rock. From the experimental results and analysis based on Mohr-Coulomb and modified Hoek-Brown criteria, it is observed that the strength of rock decreased from 0° to 30° and the rock strength is continuously increased from 30° to 90°. Simulation of failure patterns in tested specimens are matched to anisotropy planes from 0° to 30°. As per above conclusion the natural foliation (anisotropic) behaviour is catastrophically affected on a strength and failure modes of Chamoli rock. | Anisotropic rocks, Natural foliation, Chamoli rock, metamorphic rocks, Modulus anisotropy, Triaxial system
T07: Geological risks and natural hazardsJeane Mokgadi MATSOBANE (1), Bryan Philip WATSON (2)1: Sibanye Stillwater, South Africa; 2: The University of the Witwatersrand, South AfricaAssessment of face area hangingwall stability in a hard rock bord and pillar mineThe aim of this project was to assist Triggered Action Response Plan teams to issue rapid yet comprehensive support recommendations in a production environment. The research was conducted in a shallow tabular hard-rock environment in a bord and pillar mining configuration. The assessment included evaluations of bord hangingwall behaviour under various geotechnical conditions, bord spans, face advances per blast, and the influence of the last line of permanent support. The results showed that the effectiveness of the last line of support is influenced by keyblock dimensions, particularly the perimeter exposure of these blocks in the hangingwall. A reduction in span and advance per blast were found to be beneficial in reducing the height of the potential falls of ground. A set of common failure conditions has been assessed and discontinuity orientations description is provided. The description of the condition is accompanied by recommendations of support configuration or suitable spans. | Face area, TARP, FOGs, Hangingwall, span
T07: Geological risks and natural hazardsChristian BINDER, Anna FREUIS, Michael SCHREINER, Mathias SMESNIKAFRY Austria GmbH, AustriaRockfall hazards – Risk assessment, benefit/cost analysis and the design of flexible rockfall protection systemsRockfalls are a major threat to society and infrastructure in mountainous regions. The extension of settlement areas, linked with an increase in traffic combined with the people’s need for safety while driving on roads, make rockfall risk assessments and the employment of technical rockfall protection solutions indispensable. However, it is impossible to eliminate all economic and social risks caused by rockfall in mountainous regions. Risk assessments combined with benefit/cost analysis aim to reduce the risk in a structured and transparent framework to an acceptable level while maintaining cost efficiency. Technical risk reduction solutions like flexible rockfall barriers, etc. are effective but costly considering the initial investment and maintenance. This paper discusses the methodology and elements of a conducted risk assessment along with a benefit/cost analysis and how the same was used in the decision-making process of a rockfall hazard mitigation project for a section of a federal road in Austria. | Natural Hazards, Rockfall, Risk Concept, Risk Assessment, Benefit/Cost Analysis
T07: Geological risks and natural hazardsAhmed HOSNI, Claire MYR, Bastien COLAS, Isabelle HALFON, Yannick THIERY, Karim BEN SLIMANEBRGM, 3 avenue Claude Guillemin, Orléans, FranceStudy of the influence of anthropogenic galleries on the chalk cliff stability at Normandy region (France)The chalk cliffs are regularly subject to mass collapse phenomena in Normandy region (France). These instabilities represent some problems to manage for local authorities. In some cases, the chalk cliffs contain one or more galleries of anthropogenic origin and hazard assessment should integrate these particular contexts. Numerical modelling was developed in 2022 in order to quantify the influence of galleries on cliff’s stability. We studied the behavior of the {cliff + gallery} set according to parameters as the dimensions of galleries, their direction in comparison to the cliff direction (parallel or perpendicular), the superposition of exploited levels, the rock mass discontinuities, the mechanical properties of the overburden layers, etc. A scoring method is presented based on attribution of scores to the main parameters to determine the gallery influence on cliff’s stability. | Chalk, Cliff, gallery, stability, fracture, collapse, numerical model, distinct element method, plastic, mechanic, scoring
T07: Geological risks and natural hazardsFelipe GOBBI (1), Bruno DENARDIN DA ROSA (1), Dione Henrique DIAS (1), Fabio BERTUOL (1), Nataly AYUMI TOMA (1), Adoniran COELHO (2)1: FGS Geotecnia, Brazil; 2: ValeURUCUM Mine: Rockfall protection and monitoring systemThe access to Urucum mine is at the base of the Morraria de Urucum, composed of sedimentary rocks, a very steep rockface. Several rockfalls events in the past required that the company take action to mitigate risks, leading to a diagnostic and protective measures. Initially, the analyzes were based only on a point cloud, due access restrictions related to the pandemic period, resulting in a preliminary design of rockfall barriers and drainage. With the conceptual design, an extensive field mapping was performed, and the project revised, culminating in a drastic reduction of necessary interventions. The optimization it was possible through identification of differential weathering in the jaspilite strata, which allowed a new geomechanical model, better probabilistic analysis of block size distribution and thousands of rockfall simulations. This case is an interesting example of how the use of modern tools helps in projects, but it shows that they should be used with caution. | Rockfall, field mapping, point could, rockfall barrier, probabilistic analysis
T07: Geological risks and natural hazardsRainer KIENREICH, Alexander KLUCKNER, Thomas MARCHERInstitute of Rock Mechanics and Tunnelling, Graz University of Technology, Graz, AustriaRock Fall Risk – Modular Risk Management ProcessRockfall is an alpine phenomenon and must be understood as a risk. Due to the large number of events, detailed geotechnical investigations are not possible in many cases. In this article, a processing workflow is presented that enables an evaluation of a natural rockfall trigger risk. The trigger risk as well as the extent of damage are categorized in a risk matrix. The study of 485 outcrops at several rock slopes shows that without groundwater influence, predominantly stable conditions exist; with groundwater, the stability drops by around 20 %. In the case of a risk value of the "high" class, individual case assessments are necessary; in the case of the "medium" classification, organizational measures are required to minimize liability. | Rockfall, risk management, trigger risk, liability
T07: Geological risks and natural hazardsJian HUANG, Jingqing YUAN, Jianhong LIAOState Key Laboratory of Geohazard Prevention and Geoenvironment Protection, People's Republic of ChinaNumerical analysis of rockfall fragmentation mechanismFragmental rockfall is one kind of common geological disaster in mountainous areas. In this paper, the discrete element method, particle flow code (PFC) is used to simulate the impact and fracture process of rock mass, analysis the impact process of rock mass at different falling heights and impact angles, and the variation trend of impact force, velocity and the number of cracks in the rock mass. The results show that the velocity of rock mass decreases sharply and the crack develops rapidly after impact on the slope. With the increase in falling height, the rock mass velocity changes in a "second step shape", and the number of broken blocks increases while decreasing the rock mass size. With the increase of slope angle, the "double peak phenomenon" of impact force becomes less obvious. The results provide a theoretical basis for the numerical simulation of fragmental rockfall and hazard assessment. | fragmental rockfall; PFC; impact angle; impact force
T07: Geological risks and natural hazardsLianjin TAO, Zhigang WANG, Zhibo JIABeijing University of Technology, People's Republic of ChinaFailure mechanism of the utility tunnel with flexible joints under reverse fault dislocationThe earthquake-damaged investigation found that tunnel structures crossed the active fault zone, and its affected area suffered the most severe damage. Through model tests and numerical simulations, the paper reveals the failure mechanism of the utility tunnel structure with flexible joints across the active fault zone. The results show that the damage range of the utility tunnel structure with flexible joints in the hanging wall is significantly larger than that of the footwall. The damage range is 2.5D and 1.25D, respectively. The utility tunnel structure is prone to stress concentration and damage in the corner area. The damage degree of the lining structure is classified according to the tensile damage factors, namely, no damage, slight damage, moderate damage, and severe damage. Combining the large deformation of flexible joints can effectively improve the design of tunnel structures across the fault zones and improve the seismic performance of tunnel structures. | Reverse fault; Utility tunnel; Flexible joint; Model test; Numercial simulation; mechanical response
T07: Geological risks and natural hazardsOlivier BUZZI, Davide GUCCIONEPriority Research Centre for Geotechnical Science and Engineering, The University of Newcastle, AustraliaEffect of shape on the survival probability of rock replicas during free fall testsFragmentation of rocks upon impact is a complex phenomenon that is not well understood. The first question to answer to adequately model fragmentation is whether a falling block is likely to fragment at impact or not. This question can be answered if the survival probability of the rock is known, but this is not trivial as no model or method exists to predict the survival probability of natural rocks. The authors have recently developed a model that can predict the survival probability of brittle rocks under collinear impact, following a preliminary breakthrough for brittle spheres. One complexity associated with irregularly shaped rocks is the possibility of non-collinear or eccentric impacts. The objective of this study is to conduct drop tests on irregularly shaped rocks and highlight the significance of collinear and eccentric impacts on the survival probability in drop tests. | Rockfall, Fragmentation, Shape, Survival Probability, Collinear, Eccentric
T07: Geological risks and natural hazardsAbhijeet SINGH, Deepanshu SHIROLEIndian Institute of Technology, Delhi, IndiaExperimental simulation of mass flow characteristics for evaluation of the role of flow-bed roughnessOne of the significant geohazards associated with rock slopes is the avalanche. The mechanisms associated with such events are commonly studied under controlled settings of a laboratory scale analog as typical field conditions are inherently complex and uncertain. Accordingly, in this study, experiments on a novel laboratory-scale avalanche simulating system were performed to examine the flow and deposit characteristics of dry granular silica sand with the help of high-speed camera. The model consists of a fully regulated rigid flow-bed (0.6 m), on which the tests were performed at 36o, 42o and 47o angles of inclination, with frictionless (mica) and rough (P120 sandpaper) surfaces. The results showed that: (i) runout and deposit length on a smooth bed were greater than those on a rough surface, (ii) the height and width of deposit were greater on rough surfaces, and (iii) deposit width was not significantly affected by changes in the inclination angle. | Avalanche, bed friction, dry granular flow, granular mass deposit characteristics
T07: Geological risks and natural hazardsKosuke KAWATA (1), Minaho FUKUSHIMA (1), Akira MATSUOKA (1), Atsushi KUSAKA (2), Nobuharu ISAGO (1)1: Tokyo Metropolitan University, Japan; 2: Public Works Research Institute, JapanCharacteristics of reinforcement for earthquake resistance in mountain tunnelIn Japan, some mountain tunnels are damaged by earthquakes and relative large-scale deformations such as the collapse of permanent lining and the deformation of supports have occurred. Although the earthquake resistant countermeasures for tunnels has been examined recently, some countermeasures for existing tunnels are performed on the result of tunnel inspection rather than the need against earthquake resistance. To clarify the effects and the mechanical behavior of countermeasures, the model experiment was conducted assuming the structure of actual road tunnels. The collapse mechanism was compared among the cases when various kinds of reinforcement to tunnel were performed, such as rockbolts, fiber sheet and rebar. Results showed that the improvement of load-bearing capacity of the tunnel was limited, however the prevention of falling concrete blocks from structure could be expected. | mountain tunnel, earthquake, seismic measures, rehabilitation measures, experiment
T07: Geological risks and natural hazardsBenjamin COUGHLAN (1), Christian SAMPALEANU (2), Glyn WILLIAMS-JONES (1), Doug STEAD (1)1: Simon Fraser University, Canada; 2: Klohn Crippen BergerRockfall instability on high granitic domes: Stawamus Chief, B.C., CanadaThe rock slope stability of high granitic-granodiorite domes has become of increasing concern over recent decades. As tourism increases in popularity the risk posed by rockfall from these domes has also increased. Using the 417 m high Stawamus Chief, in Squamish, BC, Canada as a case study, we describe the use of multi-sensor remote sensing in understanding the failure mechanisms and the factors controlling instability. The Grand Wall and the North Wall of Stawamus Chief experienced significant rockfalls in 2021. Remote sensing using LiDAR and thermal imaging has added to our understanding of rockfall at Stawamus Chief. The application of these methods is discussed through detailed characterization of the rock slopes. Evidence shows that potential causal failure processes include root jacking, freeze-thaw effects, heavy precipitation, and expansion of joints due to extreme heat. | Geohazards, Remote Sensing, Slope Stability, Rock Mechanics, Rockfall
T07: Geological risks and natural hazardsNathalie CONIL (1), Clara MAGHAMI (2), Marwan ALHEIB (1), Philippe GOMBERT (1)1: Ineris, France; 2: Ecole des MinesImpact of climate change on the collapse of shallow mines – feedback from FranceFor many years, Ineris has been conducting research on the impact of climate change on the stability of abandoned mines. In this context, work has been initiated to reference cases of shallow mine collapses. So far, 480 cases have been identified and described. Preliminary analysis of the information gathered shows that 50% of the cases correspond relate to chalk mines, 32% to limestone mines, and 16% to gypsum mines. Two case studies presented in the paper were also analyzed in more detail. Complexity of the water-rock interaction and the importance of studying more precisely the various parameters impacted and their relationships are highlighted. Therefore, a chalk mine located in Seine-et-Marne (France) was instrumented to monitor the evolution of the structure over time and analyze the different causes of degradation. The objectives are to better understand the behavior of these structures to be able to detect precursor signs to these collapses. | shallow abandoned mines, aging, collapse, climate change, water-rock interaction
T07: Geological risks and natural hazardsKatsumi KAMEMURAFukada Geological Institute, JapanSeismic resistance evaluation based on earthquake damage survey data of mountain tunnelsTunnels constructed in the rock formation have been considered safe against earthquakes. However, the 1995 Hyogo-ken Nanbu Earthquake (M7.3) caused large damages to mountain tunnels as many as to other structures. Tunnels are one of the important infrastructures, so the evaluation of seismic resistance is a very important issue. Here damage reports on the 1923 Kanto Earthquake, the 1995 Hyogo-ken Nanbu Earthquake, the 2004 Niigata-ken Chuetsu Earthquake and others in total seven earthquakes are studied and the seismic resistance is evaluated as in the relationship between the seismic intensity and the damage rate. Using this relationship and the earthquake probability provided by official organization, the seismic risk that is very useful tool to plan appropriate earthquake countermeasures can be evaluated. | Mountain tunnel, Seismic damage, Seismic resistance evaluation, Seismic risk
T07: Geological risks and natural hazardsMaddalena MARCHELLI, Valerio DE BIAGIPolitecnico di Torino, ItalyEvent tree analysis and time-integrated reliability design approach for quantifying rockfall risk reductionThe quantification of risk in terms of loss of lives represents the essential parameter to manage rockfall risk in urbanized areas. Rockfall barriers are among the most adopted structural mitigation measures. Despite their wide use, the partial safety factors design approach is not able to guarantee a specific failure probability and, consequently, to assess the precise risk reduction. To tackle all these issues, a quantitative risk assessment method for infrastructures and a time-integrated reliability design approach for rockfall barriers developed by the Authors are combined in a unique framework to quantify risk reduction. The former computes the risk as annual probability of having at least one fatality; the latter allows defining an annual failure probability for a given product in a given site. Merging these methods, the evaluation of risk reduction in case of barrier installation or the definition of the required performances, are defined. An example of application is provided. | Rockfall Risk, Reliability based design, Event tree Analysis, Rockfall barrier
T07: Geological risks and natural hazardsJoão Paulo MONTICELLI, Rogerio RIBEIROSão Carlos School of Engineering University of São Paulo, São Paulo, BrazilA study case of a rockfall event in a geomorphosite from the Corumbataí Geopark Project, state of São Paulo, BrazilMany geomorphosites are under a natural risk scenario, as those from the Corumbataí Geopark Project, state of São Paulo, Brazil. This paper shows a rock fall event in the Camelo Hill geomorphosite. The area is used by walkers, climbers, mountaineers and civilians in general as a touristic spot in the Geopark domain. In October 2022, a boulder fell from the cliff and destroyed many trees along the slope until stopping at the dirt road used for local tourism. Herein, we have identified the rock detachment source area using field investigations and UAV mapping; an inventory of rockfalls was created and compared to the recent event. Characteristics of the rock travel distance were raised to guide the local authorities. This study also presents a new kind of source area, a rock fall conceptual model for tropical conditions, created to elucidate the mass movement to civilians. | Rock fall, drone, conceptual model, travel distance, geomorphosite, geopark
T07: Geological risks and natural hazardsAdeline DELONCACenter for Research and Innovation in Mining (CIIM), Geomechanics Research Group, Department of Metallurgical Engineering and Materials, Universidad Técnica Federico Santa María, Santiago, ChilePredicting geomechanical hazard: utopia or reality?Geomechanical hazard can be defined as a combination of the probability occurrence of an event and its intensity. Therefore, predicting a hazard level should give information about how (phenomenology of the failure), when (exact time of failure), and how much (with which intensity in terms of volume and energy) the event will occur. Several methods have been developed over the years to assess some or all these components. However, they do not allow a prediction to be made in terms of the time, location, and magnitude of the event. Indeed, in this assessment process, uncertainties are met at each step. Therefore, the prediction could be reached by answering two questions: can we remove all uncertainty? And if we do not have any uncertainty: are we able to predict the hazard? This paper proposed to discuss the two presented questions by going through various works realized during the author’s academic career. | Geomechanical hazard, uncertainties, risk assessment, prediction
T07: Geological risks and natural hazardsGiulia TORSELLO (1), Marta CASTELLI (1), Michele MORELLI (2)1: Politecnico di Torino, Italy; 2: ARPA Piemonte, Regional Agency for the Protection of the Environment, Turin, ItalyThe collapse of Torrione Sucai (Mt. Viso, Italy): rockfall analysis and data calibrationIn December 2019 a large collapse affected the Torrione Sucai, a rocky structure located on the North-Eastern slope of Mt. Viso (Italy) at about 3100 m a.s.l. Mt Viso has been included in the UNESCO World Heritage Sites since 2013 as a biosphere reserve. Therefore, hazard and risk assessment is a priority for the protection of people and the environment. The rockfall was triggered by a combination of high fracturing of the rock mass and permafrost degradation, with associated phenomena that weakened the rock mass and created conditions for slope instability. This study entails a multi-scale analysis of fracture distribution and intersections, in order to identify the zones most prone to collapse. Moreover, a multi-scale back analysis of the run-out behavior of the 2019 rockfall was performed. The results were used to calibrate preliminary susceptibility analyses for the entire area, presented and discussed in the paper. | climate change, permafrost degradation, rockfall, Italian Alps, Mt. Viso